Search This Blog

Thursday, June 28, 2012

US Supreme Court health care decision


828 days ago Congress passed health care legislation, the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act, signed by President Obama. The legislation was examined by the US Supreme Court at the request of 26 states arguing Congress exceeded its power in passing the law, which compels people to buy a product.

The Court reviewed four questions:

Was it within Congress’ constitutional powers to impose an individual mandate to purchase health insurance?

Would all or any additional parts of the law be struck down if the mandate is rejected?

Was the expansion of Medicaid unduly coercive on the states?

And, could all these questions be reviewed before the mandate takes effect?

The individual mandate issue under the commerce clause argument was rejected by the Court, but the Court ruled Congress has the power to impose the mandate because it can be considered a tax.

The Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act was upheld by the US Supreme Court in a 5-4 decision. Headlines say the Supreme Court backs all parts of President Obama’s signature health care law.

3 comments:

  1. OBAMA & The Democratic Congress & senate LIED to all of AMERICA when they stated the law was a Commerce Law & NOT a TAX.

    Well, now the Supreme court has declared that OBAMA CARE is a TAX.

    Every AMERICAN'S TAXES will be raised & this will hold back the economy.

    This TAX needs to be REPEALED. WE need a CHANGE in 2012 in the presidential race & in the Senate.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This is a great day for America. Every negative thing that has been said against Obamacare over the last couple of years was also said about Medicare during that debate in the 60's. This is MORE progress, finally. Free market healthcare does NOT work. The USA has proven that irrevocably. Healthcare is not a CHOICE that can be postponed or shopped around. If my car is giving me trouble I can CHOOSE to live with it another year or two or three. If I have a heart attack, I have to obtain healthcare or likely DIE. Oh, maybe there is a choice after all !!!

    ReplyDelete
  3. OBAMA CARE now called OBAMA TAX will be the largest TAX increase in AMERICAN History.
    Repealing it is the only way to stop this SOCIALISTIC TAX.

    For those that love it or think that America is not about CHOICE then why live here? Go to Canada or Europe where socialized medicine is ongoing.
    Stand in their lines for medical attention.

    As an AMERICAN I do not want SOCIALISM, I like FREEDOM OF CHOICE. I am adult enough to make that decision, do not need BIG DADDY OBAMA or Mommy Pelosi to make that decision for me.

    This is AMERICA where we have a right to VOTE in TAXES, not have them put upon us with LIES in order to move the SOCIALIST way of life.

    Again the Democrats LIED...This is a TAX. It needs to be repealed...Change in 2012, Republican majority across the board.

    ReplyDelete